OpenTheo
00:00
00:00

From Death to life

February 28, 2023
Life and Books and Everything
Life and Books and EverythingClearly Reformed

Church attendance is declining. In this episode, Kevin reads from his recent article for WORLD Opinions where he argues for including additional data for analysis and offers a word of hope.

Share

Transcript

(music)
Greetings and salutations. This is Life and Books and Everything. I'm Kevin DeYoung.
Today I'm reading my latest from World Opinions entitled From Death to Life. Is there any way to reverse the church's declining membership? What prompted this? I was saw a tweet which I'll reference here.
I'll come up on Twitter with some dire statistics about the leading Protestant traditions, the largest ones and how they're all facing this precipitous decline.
And there is lots of bad news to go around, but looked more carefully at it and thought maybe that wasn't the entire story. And so wrote this piece on Death to Life. Is there any way to reverse the church's declining membership? I don't think people fully grasp how much of Protestant Christianity is going to die off in the next three decades.
That's an exact quotation. That was the first line of Ryan Burgess' tweet showing the age distribution of various Protestant traditions in America. Burge, a Baptist pastor who teaches at Eastern Illinois University, often posts interesting and useful graphs about religion in America.
This particular graph shows the age distribution for 26 Protestant traditions, from Lutherans to Congregationalists to Methodists to Presbyterians to Baptists to Pentecostals to non-denominational churches. Brightly colored and easy to read, the graph demonstrates at a glance that Protestant churches are considerably greater than the population at large. Hence, Burgess concluding line, "There's no major denomination where a majority are under 45 years old exclamation point." No doubt, church attendance in America is in decline.
The rise of the nuns in ONES has been well documented and younger generations are less interested in church than their parents and grandparents were, and less interested than their parents and grandparents were at the same age.
When it comes to the churching of America, there is plenty of bad news to go around and plenty of challenges ahead. And yet, Burgess' helpful graph does not support Burgess' exclamatory conclusion.
His conclusion, that quote, "There's no major denomination where a majority are under 45 years old, may be correct, but it is not demonstrated from the evidence he provides."
Burgess' data, taken from the 2020 Cooperative Election Study, only provides information, and this is key, for adults 18 years and older. The graph says nothing about the percentage of children in the various Protestant denominations. Even if one does not consider children as members of the church, as Presbyterians do, it is still misleading, not intentionally so, I'm sure.
To make a comparative statement about those 45 and over versus those under 45, when the under 45 half of the pie doesn't include anyone under 18 years old. The more accurate conclusion from the graph would be, "There's no major denomination where the number of 18 to 44 year olds is greater than the number of those over 45." Why am I belaboring this technical point? Because I believe the percentages, though probably not great for any denomination, would look more encouraging for conservative denominations if the data included children. For example, let's compare the United Methodist Church, UMC, with my denomination, the Presbyterian Church in America, PCA.
In Burgess' graph, the two denominations have an almost identical percentage of those 65 and over, 41% and 40% respectively. One might conclude then that both denominations are about to die out, but this would be to ignore the presence of children. Both denominations indicate non-communing members, that is, baptized children, in their membership statistics, giving us a rough indication of how many children are in each denomination.
The number is imperfect because many children go through a communicants class and become full members before turning 18, but the numbers can at least give us an order of magnitude. So here we go. In 2020, the United Methodist Church had 6,268,310 professing members and 449,660 baptized members.
By comparison, the PCA had 299,891 professing members in 2020 and 78,330 baptized members. I know it's easy to get lost in all those numbers, especially if you're listening to them here. The point is this.
Obviously, the PCA is a much smaller denomination, but still helpful if we compare percentages.
While baptized members were only 7% of the total membership in the Methodist Church, baptized members were 20% of the PCA's membership, or about 3 times as many by way of percentage. This is not far off the percentage of 0-18 year olds in the nation at large, 22%.
Undoubtedly, then, the PCA is in a much healthier position than the United Methodist Church. I've noted before that the mainline churches are literally dying. They have been in steep decline for almost 6 straight decades, so that year after year, mainline denominations are consistently getting older, wider, and smaller.
Many conservative denominations aren't doing great either, but they are at least doing less poorly. So what should our takeaway from yet another largely discouraging, though less so if you include children, report on the state of church membership in America? Well, three things. First, changing to fit the mood of the culture is not the answer.
Reimagined Christianity, where core doctrines are abandoned and ethical standards are thrown out the window, may appeal to the deconstructing and to cultural elites, but it is no way to win the lost. Socially acceptable liberal theology does not keep young people in the church either. According to Burgess Graf, only six Protestant traditions have at least 25% of their adult population in the 18-35 year old bracket.
All six are evangelical, as opposed to mainline. Second, if you don't want your version of Protestant Christianity to die off, the strategy is pretty simple. Have more kids, and keep them in the church.
It has always been the case that most people in the church get in the church because they were born and raised in the church. Third, when all hope seems lost, why not try God's way of reaching the lost? Preach faithfully, pray fervently, and be ready to give an answer for the hope that is in you. Ultimately, it's up to God to save sinners.
Jesus will build his church however he sees fit, but we can do our part by getting the gospel right and getting the gospel out. Those are the ingredients God still uses to bring people, churches, and denominations from death to life. Once again, my latest article in World Opinions, and a few weeks after these articles come out, you can find them on clearlyreform.org. That's where they're archived, and visit clearlyreformed.org for all of my podcast, articles, and various other resources.
[music]

More on OpenTheo

How Do You Know You Have the Right Bible?
How Do You Know You Have the Right Bible?
#STRask
April 14, 2025
Questions about the Catholic Bible versus the Protestant Bible, whether or not the original New Testament manuscripts exist somewhere and how we would
Douglas Groothuis: Morality as Evidence for God
Douglas Groothuis: Morality as Evidence for God
Knight & Rose Show
March 22, 2025
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose welcome Douglas Groothuis to discuss morality. Is morality objective or subjective? Can atheists rationally ground huma
If Jesus Is God, Why Didn’t He Know the Day of His Return?
If Jesus Is God, Why Didn’t He Know the Day of His Return?
#STRask
June 12, 2025
Questions about why Jesus didn’t know the day of his return if he truly is God, and why it’s important for Jesus to be both fully God and fully man.  
What Would Be the Point of Getting Baptized After All This Time?
What Would Be the Point of Getting Baptized After All This Time?
#STRask
May 22, 2025
Questions about the point of getting baptized after being a Christian for over 60 years, the difference between a short prayer and an eloquent one, an
If People Could Be Saved Before Jesus, Why Was It Necessary for Him to Come?
If People Could Be Saved Before Jesus, Why Was It Necessary for Him to Come?
#STRask
March 24, 2025
Questions about why it was necessary for Jesus to come if people could already be justified by faith apart from works, and what the point of the Old C
Why Do Some Churches Say You Need to Keep the Mosaic Law?
Why Do Some Churches Say You Need to Keep the Mosaic Law?
#STRask
May 5, 2025
Questions about why some churches say you need to keep the Mosaic Law and the gospel of Christ to be saved, and whether or not it’s inappropriate for
Licona vs. Fales: A Debate in 4 Parts – Part Three: The Meaning of Miracle Stories
Licona vs. Fales: A Debate in 4 Parts – Part Three: The Meaning of Miracle Stories
Risen Jesus
June 11, 2025
In this episode, we hear from Dr. Evan Fales as he presents his case against the historicity of Jesus’ resurrection and responds to Dr. Licona’s writi
Is It Wrong to Feel Satisfaction at the Thought of Some Atheists Being Humbled Before Christ?
Is It Wrong to Feel Satisfaction at the Thought of Some Atheists Being Humbled Before Christ?
#STRask
June 9, 2025
Questions about whether it’s wrong to feel a sense of satisfaction at the thought of some atheists being humbled before Christ when their time comes,
Mythos or Logos: How Should the Narratives about Jesus' Resurreciton Be Understood? Licona/Craig vs Spangenberg/Wolmarans
Mythos or Logos: How Should the Narratives about Jesus' Resurreciton Be Understood? Licona/Craig vs Spangenberg/Wolmarans
Risen Jesus
April 16, 2025
Dr. Mike Licona and Dr. Willian Lane Craig contend that the texts about Jesus’ resurrection were written to teach a physical, historical resurrection
Should We Not Say Anything Against Voodoo?
Should We Not Say Anything Against Voodoo?
#STRask
March 27, 2025
Questions about how to respond to someone who thinks we shouldn’t say anything against Voodoo since it’s “just their culture” and arguments to refute
More on the Midwest and Midlife with Kevin, Collin, and Justin
More on the Midwest and Midlife with Kevin, Collin, and Justin
Life and Books and Everything
May 19, 2025
The triumvirate comes back together to wrap up another season of LBE. Along with the obligatory sports chatter, the three guys talk at length about th
How Should I Respond to the Phrase “Just Follow the Science”?
How Should I Respond to the Phrase “Just Follow the Science”?
#STRask
March 31, 2025
Questions about how to respond when someone says, “Just follow the science,” and whether or not it’s a good tactic to cite evolutionists’ lack of a go
Licona and Martin: A Dialogue on Jesus' Claim of Divinity
Licona and Martin: A Dialogue on Jesus' Claim of Divinity
Risen Jesus
May 14, 2025
In this episode, Dr. Mike Licona and Dr. Dale Martin discuss their differing views of Jesus’ claim of divinity. Licona proposes that “it is more proba
Interview with Chance: Patriarchy and Incarnational Christianity
Interview with Chance: Patriarchy and Incarnational Christianity
For The King
April 2, 2025
The True Myth Podcast if you want to hear more from Chance! Parallel Christian Economy⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Reflectedworks.com⁠⁠ ⁠⁠USE PROMO CODE: FORT
The Resurrection - Argument from Personal Incredulity or Methodological Naturalism - Licona vs. Dillahunty - Part 2
The Resurrection - Argument from Personal Incredulity or Methodological Naturalism - Licona vs. Dillahunty - Part 2
Risen Jesus
March 26, 2025
In this episode, Dr. Licona provides a positive case for the resurrection of Jesus at the 2017 [UN]Apologetic Conference in Austin, Texas. He bases hi