OpenTheo

Q&A#158 Supersessionism

Alastair Roberts

Q&A#158 Supersessionism

November 21, 2019
Alastair Roberts
Alastair Roberts

Today's question: "I have just read your very intelligent contribution to the series of Articles at Theopolis on the relation of Israel to the Church. I would describe myself as supersessionist, but in the sense that Israel and the Church are one, because the Church, rather than a newly created covenant people in parallel with ethnic Israel, is the crucified and resurrected people of the covenant established in the calling of Abraham, which has been brought to a greater level of glory and maturity in Christ. In this way of thinking, the only supersession, or replacement, which has taken place, is the substitution of believing Gentiles for unbelieving Jews in the olive tree of Israel.

I nevertheless believe that Romans 8-11 speaks of a national conversion of the Jewish people at the end of this age. It is also quite apparent that in spite of their rejection of Christ, Paul believes that they are loved of God and retain their uniqueness as the appointed messengers of his salvation for the sake of the nations.

But insofar as they have rejected Christ, who is the yes of the Father unto all the promises made unto Israel, how are we to understand Paul's assertion about the "gifts and callings of God" to them being "irrevocable"? It is difficult, for example, to comprehend how their "callings", if we are to understand that as a reference to their priestly vocation as a light to the nations, is capable of being realized so long as they reject Christ.

Any light you can shed for me on this mystery would be greatly appreciated."

If you have any questions or feedback, please send them to me on Curious Cat: https://curiouscat.me/zugzwanged.

If you have enjoyed my output, please tell your friends. If you are interested in supporting my videos and podcasts and my research more generally, please consider supporting my work on Patreon (https://www.patreon.com/zugzwanged), using my PayPal account (https://bit.ly/2RLaUcB), or by buying books for my research on Amazon (https://www.amazon.co.uk/hz/wishlist/ls/36WVSWCK4X33O?ref_=wl_share).

The audio of all of my videos is available on my Soundcloud account: https://soundcloud.com/alastairadversaria. You can also listen to the audio of these episodes on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/alastairs-adversaria/id1416351035?mt=2.

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

#219 Title Why don’t I hear from God any more? (Replay)
#219 Title Why don’t I hear from God any more? (Replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
May 30, 2024
Join Tom today as he sits down to answer a fresh batch of questions from listeners who are having trouble hearing from God. Nicole asks why 'Ask and y
Does the Bible Teach That Elijah Was Reincarnated as John the Baptist?
Does the Bible Teach That Elijah Was Reincarnated as John the Baptist?
#STRask
May 9, 2024
Questions about responding to someone who says the Bible teaches reincarnation when it says John the Baptist “is Elijah who was to come” in Matthew 11
#225 Will animals go to heaven? Are NDEs real? Is there 'free will' in heaven?  (replay)
#225 Will animals go to heaven? Are NDEs real? Is there 'free will' in heaven?  (replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
July 11, 2024
In this episode, Tom dives into listener questions about heaven and the new creation. Discover whether free will still exists in heaven, what near-dea
Your Identity in Christ and the Difference it Makes
Your Identity in Christ and the Difference it Makes
Knight & Rose Show
June 8, 2024
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose discuss the concept of "identity in Christ". We discuss how your identity in Christ changes your desires, capabilities,
Drinking, Merriment, and Heaven
Drinking, Merriment, and Heaven
For The King
May 8, 2024
What is the biblical view of alcohol? https://fortheking.substack.com/p/drinking-merriment-and-heaven Parallel Christian Economy * ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Ref
Is Post-Mortem Salvation an Orthodox Doctrine?
Is Post-Mortem Salvation an Orthodox Doctrine?
#STRask
July 11, 2024
Questions about whether post-mortem salvation is an orthodox doctrine, reconciling a verse about God removing our transgressions from us with verses a
The Internet is the Negative World
The Internet is the Negative World
Alastair Roberts
May 14, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/33-the-internet-is-the-negative-world. Within it, I discuss Aaron Renn's rece
#220 Understanding the Concept of Satan in the Bible (Replay)
#220 Understanding the Concept of Satan in the Bible (Replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
June 6, 2024
Tom answers listeners questions on the question of Satan and the powers of evil. Are we supposed to believe in a literal Satan? Explore with Tom Wrigh
Doesn’t Acts Argue That Not All Believers Receive the Holy Spirit?
Doesn’t Acts Argue That Not All Believers Receive the Holy Spirit?
#STRask
July 8, 2024
Questions about why we should think the new believers in Acts 5:14 received the Holy Spirit when Acts seems to argue that not all believers necessaril
Lydia McGrew Answered! On Gospel Differences
Lydia McGrew Answered! On Gospel Differences
Risen Jesus
June 26, 2024
In this episode, part 7 in an 8 part series, Dr. Licona reviews several events in the Gospels to demonstrate how compositional devices are more plausi
Casey Luskin: Debunking the Myth of Junk DNA
Casey Luskin: Debunking the Myth of Junk DNA
Knight & Rose Show
June 22, 2024
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose interview Dr. Casey Luskin about junk DNA. Is your DNA assembled by undirected forces, or is it intelligently designed?
Was Jesus’ Death Really a Sacrifice if He Knew He Would Rise Again?
Was Jesus’ Death Really a Sacrifice if He Knew He Would Rise Again?
#STRask
June 24, 2024
Questions about why God the Father required a sacrifice (and whether Jesus’ short-term death was really a sacrifice), whether Jesus’ disciples ever of
Petrus Van Mastricht's Theoretical-Practical Theology with Todd Rester
Petrus Van Mastricht's Theoretical-Practical Theology with Todd Rester
Life and Books and Everything
May 1, 2024
What are you doing with your life? Todd Rester is using a big chunk of his life to translate a seventeenth-century Dutch theologian's magnum opus (all
What Apologetics Strategies Can We Use with Agnostics?
What Apologetics Strategies Can We Use with Agnostics?
#STRask
May 30, 2024
Questions about apologetics strategies to use with an agnostic who says it’s pointless to worry about whether there is a God because we can’t know if
Won’t Jesus Only Be Able to Interact with One Person at a Time?
Won’t Jesus Only Be Able to Interact with One Person at a Time?
#STRask
June 27, 2024
Questions about how being with Jesus continually will be the highlight of eternity if he’ll only be able to interact with one person at a time since h