OpenTheo
00:00
00:00

Lessons From Mainline Decline

May 4, 2022
Life and Books and Everything
Life and Books and EverythingClearly Reformed

Relevant Christianity doesn’t stay relevant for long.

In this episode of Life and Books and Everything, Kevin reads from the article he wrote for WORLD Opinions on the decline of the mainline church.

Share

Transcript

Greetings and Salutations, this is Life and Books and Everything. I'm Kevin DeYoung and I'm reading a piece from World Opinions, my piece entitled Lessons From Mainline Decline. The PCUSA is literally dying.
I grew up in the mainline church and it won't be until I'm nearly 80 years old that I will have spent more of my life outside the mainline church than inside it. I was born, baptized, confirmed, and ordained in the Reformed Church in America, a smallish, originally dutch denomination that, with its roots dating back to 1628 in New Amsterdam, both of being the oldest Protestant denomination with the continuing ministry in the United States, I'm thankful for the many good people, good churches and good pastors in the RCA. I met Jesus in the RCA so there will always be reasons for gratitude.
But somewhere in my college years at an RCA school, I realized that the denomination I grew up in was considered a part of the mainline tradition. So named for the affluent suburbs along Philadelphia's main railroad line, the term mainline Protestant, came to be synonymous with the old denominations that broke toward modernism, instead of fundamentalism, and often wore the label ecumenical, even though some of them still claim to be evangelical. If you aren't a baby boomer or a student of religious history, it can be hard to fathom the cultural influence and social cohesion that once resided in mainline Protestantism.
At its height in 1965, mainline Protestant churches counted 31 million members out of a US population of less than 200 million.
Most Protestants were in the mainline denominations and the country's cultural norms were set, for better or for worse, by the old school Protestant establishment. Almost 60 years later, all of that has changed.
In its recently released demographic report, the Presbyterian Church USA, announced it lost another 51,584 members.
From a membership peak of 4.25 million in 1965, the PCUSA roles are now down to 1.19 million. And that membership decline hardly conveys the severity of the situation.
In the last reporting year, the denomination dissolved 104 congregations in dropped four presbyteries.
More than 40% of the congregations have fewer than 50 members. Almost a third of the denomination is more than 70 years old, and another 26% are older than 55.
Keep in mind that only 16% of Americans are 65 or older. The PCUSA is literally dying. While my denomination, the conservative Presbyterian Church in America has hardly been growing by leaps and bounds over the past few years, it is a model of health compared to its mainline counterpart.
Even though the historic PCUSA has almost 9,000 churches and more than a million members, and the denomination come lately PCA, founded in 1973, has only 1,600 churches and not quite 400,000 members, the PCA has almost half the income of the PCUSA nearly as many ministerial candidates. And in 2020, had more infant baptisms, which probably starts with having more infants. Congregations in conservative denominations, like the PCA, are on the whole, bigger, younger, and multiplying in ways the mainline is not.
Of course, we must not think that conservative churches and denominations always grow, or at least hold their ground, and liberal churches and denominations always shrink. Evangelical churches face plenty of their own challenges, but two factors make the decline of the mainline noteworthy as a cautionary tale. First, the mainline church, despite its emphasis on diversity, equity, and inclusion, has been spectacularly unsuccessful in appealing to minorities.
The PCUSA has tried to do all the right progressive things on race for decades, like including the category Latinx in its report, and yet the denomination is more than 88% white, only 1.61% Hispanic and only 4.39% black, and that includes Africans. The gospel of diversity does not bring various peoples together nearly as well as the gospel of the cross. Second, theological liberalism is by definition supposed to be attuned to the times in which we live.
As Gary Dorian puts it in the making of American liberal theology, since the 18th century, liberal Christian thinkers have argued that religion should be modern and progressive, and that the meaning of Christianity should be interpreted from the standpoint of modern knowledge and experience. In other words, if any ecclesiastical tradition should be relevant for people today, one would think it should be the mainline. Here, for example, are the headlines that the Presbyterian outlook had at the time of this writing listed on its current affairs page before its article about the PCUSA statistical report.
Here are the headlines, "The climate crisis is increasingly a refugee crisis." Another one, "Finding diversity and equity in investing decisions." And a third, "We've got to move Earth Day to 12 months a year." Well, that's one way to quote "reinterpret Christianity for modern people." It's just not a Christianity that's going to compel new people to give up their Sunday mornings. And that's the rub. Relevant Christianity doesn't stay relevant for long.
Reinterpreted Christianity may appeal to the deconstructing, but it does not win the hearts and minds of the lost. We have no guarantee that faithful churches will thrive, but after almost 60 years of constant mainline decline, we have a pretty good idea of how churches die. I'd like to share a few of these things that I would like to share with you.
I'd like to share a few of these things that I would like to share with you. I'd like to share a few of these things that I would like to share with you. I'd like to share a few of these things that I would like to share with you.
[ Silence ]

More From Life and Books and Everything

Hoping for the Fall of Roe with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Hoping for the Fall of Roe with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Life and Books and Everything
May 10, 2022
After the unprecedented leak of the possible Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, Kevin talks to Justin and Collin about the pro-life movem
Seven Principles for Cultivating a Christian Posture toward the World
Seven Principles for Cultivating a Christian Posture toward the World
Life and Books and Everything
May 13, 2022
Important lessons to learn as we deal with negativity and hostility In this episode of Life and Books and Everything, Kevin reads from the article he
The Heart of the Cross with Phil Ryken
The Heart of the Cross with Phil Ryken
Life and Books and Everything
May 17, 2022
Kevin welcomes Phil Ryken, President at Wheaton College, to the podcast to talk about “The Heart of the Cross,” a newly reissued book comprised of ser
Daily Worship, Creation Days, and Feisty Presbyterians with Jonathan Gibson
Daily Worship, Creation Days, and Feisty Presbyterians with Jonathan Gibson
Life and Books and Everything
April 26, 2022
In this freewheeling conversation, Kevin talks to Jonny Gibson about his life, his books, and some of everything. Gibson, an Old Testament professor a
John Witherspoon on Justification and Regeneration with Peter Lillback
John Witherspoon on Justification and Regeneration with Peter Lillback
Life and Books and Everything
April 18, 2022
In this bonus episode, Kevin talks with historian and WTS president, Peter Lillback, about the life and ministry of John Witherspoon. In particular, t
The Story of Us All
The Story of Us All
Life and Books and Everything
April 15, 2022
The fundamental story of the world is not the story of good guys and bad guys, or of oppressors and the oppressed, but of sinners and a Savior. In thi
More From "Life and Books and Everything"

More on OpenTheo

Could Inherently Sinful Humans Have Accurately Recorded the Word of God?
Could Inherently Sinful Humans Have Accurately Recorded the Word of God?
#STRask
July 7, 2025
Questions about whether or not inherently sinful humans could have accurately recorded the Word of God, whether the words about Moses in Acts 7:22 and
If Sin Is a Disease We’re Born with, How Can We Be Guilty When We Sin?
If Sin Is a Disease We’re Born with, How Can We Be Guilty When We Sin?
#STRask
June 19, 2025
Questions about how we can be guilty when we sin if sin is a disease we’re born with, how it can be that we’ll have free will in Heaven but not have t
Bible Study: Choices and Character in James, Part 1
Bible Study: Choices and Character in James, Part 1
Knight & Rose Show
June 21, 2025
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose explore chapters 1 and 2 of the Book of James. They discuss the book's author, James, the brother of Jesus, and his mar
Is It Problematic for a DJ to Play Songs That Are Contrary to His Christian Values?
Is It Problematic for a DJ to Play Songs That Are Contrary to His Christian Values?
#STRask
July 10, 2025
Questions about whether it’s problematic for a DJ on a secular radio station to play songs with lyrics that are contrary to his Christian values, and
Licona vs. Fales: A Debate in 4 Parts – Part Three: The Meaning of Miracle Stories
Licona vs. Fales: A Debate in 4 Parts – Part Three: The Meaning of Miracle Stories
Risen Jesus
June 11, 2025
In this episode, we hear from Dr. Evan Fales as he presents his case against the historicity of Jesus’ resurrection and responds to Dr. Licona’s writi
What Would You Say to an Atheist Who Claims to Lack a Worldview?
What Would You Say to an Atheist Who Claims to Lack a Worldview?
#STRask
July 17, 2025
Questions about how to handle a conversation with an atheist who claims to lack a worldview, and how to respond to someone who accuses you of being “s
An Ex-Christian Disputes Jesus' Physical Resurrection: Licona vs. Barker - Part 2
An Ex-Christian Disputes Jesus' Physical Resurrection: Licona vs. Barker - Part 2
Risen Jesus
July 16, 2025
In this episode , we have Dr. Mike Licona's first-ever debate. In 2003, Licona sparred with Dan Barker at the University of Wisonsin-Madison. Once a C
Can Historians Prove that Jesus Rose from the Dead? Licona vs. Ehrman
Can Historians Prove that Jesus Rose from the Dead? Licona vs. Ehrman
Risen Jesus
May 7, 2025
In this episode, Dr. Mike Licona and Dr. Bart Ehrman face off for the second time on whether historians can prove the resurrection. Dr. Ehrman says no
Nicene Orthodoxy with Blair Smith
Nicene Orthodoxy with Blair Smith
Life and Books and Everything
April 28, 2025
Kevin welcomes his good friend—neighbor, church colleague, and seminary colleague (soon to be boss!)—Blair Smith to the podcast. As a systematic theol
Licona and Martin: A Dialogue on Jesus' Claim of Divinity
Licona and Martin: A Dialogue on Jesus' Claim of Divinity
Risen Jesus
May 14, 2025
In this episode, Dr. Mike Licona and Dr. Dale Martin discuss their differing views of Jesus’ claim of divinity. Licona proposes that “it is more proba
Jay Richards: Economics, Gender Ideology and MAHA
Jay Richards: Economics, Gender Ideology and MAHA
Knight & Rose Show
April 19, 2025
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose welcome Heritage Foundation policy expert Dr. Jay Richards to discuss policy and culture. Jay explains how economic fre
Can a Deceased Person’s Soul Live On in the Recipient of His Heart?
Can a Deceased Person’s Soul Live On in the Recipient of His Heart?
#STRask
May 12, 2025
Questions about whether a deceased person’s soul can live on in the recipient of his heart, whether 1 Corinthians 15:44 confirms that babies in the wo
The Biblical View of Abortion with Tom Pennington
The Biblical View of Abortion with Tom Pennington
Life and Books and Everything
May 5, 2025
What does the Bible say about life in the womb? When does life begin? What about personhood? What has the church taught about abortion over the centur
Pastoral Theology with Jonathan Master
Pastoral Theology with Jonathan Master
Life and Books and Everything
April 21, 2025
First published in 1877, Thomas Murphy’s Pastoral Theology: The Pastor in the Various Duties of His Office is one of the absolute best books of its ki
An Ex-Christian Disputes Jesus' Physical Resurrection: Licona vs. Barker - Part 1
An Ex-Christian Disputes Jesus' Physical Resurrection: Licona vs. Barker - Part 1
Risen Jesus
July 9, 2025
In this episode, we have Dr. Mike Licona's first-ever debate. In 2003, Licona sparred with Dan Barker at the University of Wisonsin-Madison. Once a Ch