OpenTheo

Are Logic and Reasoning Immaterial?

#STRask — Stand to Reason

Are Logic and Reasoning Immaterial?

April 14, 2022
#STRask
#STRaskStand to Reason

Questions about whether logic and reasoning aren’t immaterial because they’re activities of a physical brain and whether the fact that some people have a “blind mind’s eye” counters the claim that the mind’s ability to visualize images is evidence for the existence of a non-physical self.

* How would you respond to someone who claims logic and reasoning aren’t immaterial because they’re activities of a physical brain?

* Does the fact that some people have a “blind mind’s eye” (aphantasia) effectively counter the claim that the mind’s ability to visualize images is evidence for the existence of a non-physical self?

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

When Does a Human Receive a Soul?
When Does a Human Receive a Soul?
#STRask
October 14, 2024
Questions about when a human receives a soul and how to respond to someone who rejects science, reason, philosophy, and objective morality in her effo
Is the Principle of Double Effect Legitimate When It Comes to Abortion?
Is the Principle of Double Effect Legitimate When It Comes to Abortion?
#STRask
October 24, 2024
Questions about the legitimacy of the principle of double effect when it comes to abortion and saving the mother’s life, whether laws should protect t
It's About Time
It's About Time
Alastair Roberts
November 26, 2024
The following was first published over on The Anchored Argosy Substack: https://argosy.substack.com/p/35-the-depths-of-time. A version of it was also
Relitigating the Deception of Isaac
Relitigating the Deception of Isaac
Alastair Roberts
September 18, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/32-intellectual-salons-and-a-new. Follow our Substack, the Anchored Argosy a
Good Samaritan Politics
Good Samaritan Politics
Alastair Roberts
September 26, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/25-good-samaritan-politics. Follow our Substack, the Anchored Argosy at http
A Critical Look at Critical Theory with Carl Trueman
A Critical Look at Critical Theory with Carl Trueman
Life and Books and Everything
October 16, 2024
In his new book To Change All Worlds: Critical Theory from Marx to Marcuse, Carl Trueman argues that “Critical theory [sees] any notion of human natur
How Can I Help Someone Move Away from the Fact-Value Split?
How Can I Help Someone Move Away from the Fact-Value Split?
#STRask
September 23, 2024
Questions about how to help a friend move away from his belief that objective facts about religious issues, unlike scientific facts, are “just someone
Election Next Steps... WISDOM NEEDED!
Election Next Steps... WISDOM NEEDED!
For The King
November 29, 2024
With the recent election Christians need to really think about how to make the best use of our time and to fight the right battles moving forward. We
What Does It Mean to Be an Evangelical? With Andrew Atherstone and David Ceri Jones
What Does It Mean to Be an Evangelical? With Andrew Atherstone and David Ceri Jones
Life and Books and Everything
October 23, 2024
A few months ago, a prominent American scholar, Matthew Avery Sutton, published an article arguing there is no “through line” from Christians of the p
What Biblical Principles Should Guide How We Vote?
What Biblical Principles Should Guide How We Vote?
#STRask
October 21, 2024
Question about what biblical principles should guide how we vote.   * What biblical principles should guide how we vote?
Evaluating the Thought of Cornelius Van Til with Keith Mathison and James Anderson
Evaluating the Thought of Cornelius Van Til with Keith Mathison and James Anderson
Life and Books and Everything
November 27, 2024
It is hard to exaggerate the influence of Cornelius Van Til (1895–1987) in conservative Reformed circles over the past hundred years. And yet, there c
What Do I Tell a Child Who Feels Guilty for Not Wanting to Read the Bible?
What Do I Tell a Child Who Feels Guilty for Not Wanting to Read the Bible?
#STRask
September 19, 2024
Questions about what to tell a child who feels guilty for not wanting to read the Bible because he finds it boring and confusing, what Bible was print
Do We Always Need to Make the Case that Christian Morality Is the Best Way to Live?
Do We Always Need to Make the Case that Christian Morality Is the Best Way to Live?
#STRask
September 26, 2024
Questions about whether Christians can simply say that God’s moral requirements are a show of loyalty to him rather than argue they’re the best way to
Are Our Physical Ailments Caused by Spiritual Warfare?
Are Our Physical Ailments Caused by Spiritual Warfare?
#STRask
December 5, 2024
Questions about whether our physical ailments are caused by spiritual warfare, how much agency demons have in light of the fact that God sometimes sen
The Anglicanism of C.S. Lewis
The Anglicanism of C.S. Lewis
Alastair Roberts
October 29, 2024
The following is a reading of a reflection first published on our Substack: https://argosy.substack.com/p/lewis-the-anglican. A version of it was also