OpenTheo

Does This Prove We Can’t Ground Objective Morality in God?

#STRask — Stand to Reason

Does This Prove We Can’t Ground Objective Morality in God?

January 25, 2024
#STRask
#STRaskStand to Reason

Question about an objection to grounding objective morality in God that states that if God has a morally perfect nature, and he either engaged in or directly allowed genocide, slavery, and torture, then that means genocide, slavery, and torture are objectively good.

* How would you address this atheist challenge to grounding objective morality in God: If God has an unchanging, morally perfect nature, and he either engaged in or directly allowed genocide, slavery, and torture, then doesn’t that mean genocide, slavery, and torture are objectively good?

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More From #STRask

If We Can’t Impose a Moral Standard from One Period of Time on Another, How Does That Affect the Moral Argument?
If We Can’t Impose a Moral Standard from One Period of Time on Another, How Does That Affect the Moral Argument?
#STRask
January 29, 2024
Questions about how one can use the moral argument and also say we can’t impose a moral standard from one period of time on another and responding to
Is Christianity Really a Story of Reality?
Is Christianity Really a Story of Reality?
#STRask
February 1, 2024
Questions about whether Christianity is about following Jesus rather than a story of reality, what John the Baptist meant when he said, “He must incre
How Can We Apply the Bible to Our Lives if We’re Not Supposed to Read Our Circumstances into It?
How Can We Apply the Bible to Our Lives if We’re Not Supposed to Read Our Circumstances into It?
#STRask
February 5, 2024
Questions about how to apply the Bible to our lives if we’re supposed to read it in context and not insert our circumstances into it and how to respon
How Concerned Should I Be about My Spouse Believing in Annihilationism?
How Concerned Should I Be about My Spouse Believing in Annihilationism?
#STRask
January 22, 2024
Questions about how concerned one should be and what to do about a spouse who now believes in annihilationism and how to navigate differences in doctr
Do These Verses Support the Idea That Everyone Will Be Saved?
Do These Verses Support the Idea That Everyone Will Be Saved?
#STRask
January 18, 2024
Question about whether Romans 5:18, 1 Corinthians 15:22, and 1 John 2:2 support the idea that everyone will be saved (universalism) as a New York Time
Is Consent to Sex Consent to Pregnancy?
Is Consent to Sex Consent to Pregnancy?
#STRask
January 15, 2024
Questions about how to respond to the claim that consent to sex is not consent to pregnancy and what to say to a Christian who argues that the law sho
More From "#STRask"

More on OpenTheo

A Fresh Look at Inerrancy: Part two
A Fresh Look at Inerrancy: Part two
Risen Jesus
September 3, 2024
What are compositional devices? How do they affect our view of inerrancy? What does the Bible say about inspiration and inerrancy? In this episode, Dr
Your Religion Prohibits You, Not Me
Your Religion Prohibits You, Not Me
#STRask
August 26, 2024
Question about how to respond to a meme that says, “Your religion does not prohibit me from anything. It prohibits you. Learn the difference.” * How
Reading, Writing, and the Olympics with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Reading, Writing, and the Olympics with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Life and Books and Everything
August 14, 2024
After a summer hiatus, the fellas are back together to kick off a new season of LBE. If you always look forward to the sports banter with these three,
Is It Okay to Pray for the Destruction and Downfall of Our Enemies?
Is It Okay to Pray for the Destruction and Downfall of Our Enemies?
#STRask
August 5, 2024
Questions about whether it’s okay to pray for the destruction and downfall of our enemies, how to reconcile the idea that God doesn’t tempt people wit
Tolkien's Best Gardener
Tolkien's Best Gardener
For The King
August 18, 2024
This is an article I wrote for jrrjokien.com For the Permaculture side project please visit heritagepermaculture.substack.com Parallel Christian Eco
Westminster Divines, Spiritual Warfare, and the Neglected Practice of Hospitality with Chad Van Dixhoorn
Westminster Divines, Spiritual Warfare, and the Neglected Practice of Hospitality with Chad Van Dixhoorn
Life and Books and Everything
September 25, 2024
It’s not everyday you get to hear from the world’s expert on the Westminster Assembly (and who among us does not wish to know more about the Westminst
Does the Bible Say That Someday Everyone Will Worship God?
Does the Bible Say That Someday Everyone Will Worship God?
#STRask
July 15, 2024
Questions about whether the Bible says that someday everyone in the world will worship God, the purpose of worshiping God, and whether it might be the
When Does a Human Receive a Soul?
When Does a Human Receive a Soul?
#STRask
October 14, 2024
Questions about when a human receives a soul and how to respond to someone who rejects science, reason, philosophy, and objective morality in her effo
How Is Access to God in the New Covenant Different from the Old Covenant?
How Is Access to God in the New Covenant Different from the Old Covenant?
#STRask
August 29, 2024
Questions about how access to God through Jesus in the New Covenant differs from access in the Old Covenant, whether the salvation of Gentiles is just
Where Did the Essence God Is Composed of Come From?
Where Did the Essence God Is Composed of Come From?
#STRask
September 5, 2024
Questions about where the essence God is composed of came from, whether God has the same choices other beings have and could choose not to exist, and
Why Mordecai Did Not Bow
Why Mordecai Did Not Bow
Alastair Roberts
October 12, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/breakfast-and-move-things. Follow our Substack, the Anchored Argosy at https
God Didn’t Save Me from My Childhood Trauma
God Didn’t Save Me from My Childhood Trauma
#STRask
August 15, 2024
Questions about how to respond to someone who rejects God because he didn’t save her from her childhood trauma when she prayed for help and whether it
A Critical Look at Critical Theory with Carl Trueman
A Critical Look at Critical Theory with Carl Trueman
Life and Books and Everything
October 16, 2024
In his new book To Change All Worlds: Critical Theory from Marx to Marcuse, Carl Trueman argues that “Critical theory [sees] any notion of human natur
What Can Be Learned From Contemporary, Non-Scriptural Greco-Roman writings?
What Can Be Learned From Contemporary, Non-Scriptural Greco-Roman writings?
Risen Jesus
August 26, 2024
In this episode, Dr. Mike Licona walks the listener through some of the discoveries revealed in his new book Jesus, Contradicted. By examining Greco-R
Isn’t It Better to Do Good for Goodness’ Sake?
Isn’t It Better to Do Good for Goodness’ Sake?
#STRask
September 2, 2024
Questions about it being better to do good for goodness’ sake rather than to earn approval and avoid punishment and a good initial approach to take wi