Q&A#98 Should We Sing Happy Birthday to Jesus at Christmas?

Alastair Roberts

Q&A#98 Should We Sing Happy Birthday to Jesus at Christmas?

December 18, 2018

Alastair Roberts

Alastair Roberts

Today's question:

"I recently ran into a new (to me?) liturgical trend that seems to be suddenly ubiquitous, and that, at least initially caught me somewhat flat footed: Celebrating Christmas by singing "Happy Birthday" to Jesus, and/or making part of the Christmas celebration a birthday party for Jesus.

My initial feeling is that this celebration is extremely misguided, and I think I can articulate some objections; but I'm having some difficulty clearly and thoroughly articulating an objection (assuming it is problematic), and I don't know how to respond well. What are your thoughts on this sort of liturgical practice, and how to respond to it well? I'm particularly concerned regarding the catechesis of my daughter.

(RE: Its ubiquity: Today our pastor said the church would sing "Happy Birthday to Jesus" in the liturgy after the Christ candle in the advent wreath is lit--as if the Christ candle were His birthday candle(!), and there'd be birthday cake for Jesus after the service; my daughter sang it as part of her preschool's Christmas celebration; and my nephew's LCMS Christmas celebration was a celebration of "The birthday of our best friend, Jesus".)"

My blog for my podcasts and videos is found here: https://adversariapodcast.com/.

If you have any questions, you can leave them on my Curious Cat account: https://curiouscat.me/zugzwanged.

If you have enjoyed these talks, please tell your friends and consider supporting me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/zugzwanged. You can also support me using my PayPal account: https://bit.ly/2RLaUcB.

The audio of all of my videos is available on my Soundcloud account: https://soundcloud.com/alastairadversaria. You can also listen to the audio of these episodes on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/alastairs-adversaria/id1416351035?mt=2.

Share

Transcript

More From Alastair Roberts

Q&A#99 Paul Maxwell on Masculinity Revisited

Q&A#99 Paul Maxwell on Masculinity Revisited

Alastair Roberts

December 19, 2018

I've been asked to give thoughts on this video/article by Paul Maxwell on evangelicalism and masculinity: https://selfwire.org/article/evangelical-cul

Q&A#100 The Bumper Hundredth Q&A Episode

Q&A#100 The Bumper Hundredth Q&A Episode

Alastair Roberts

December 20, 2018

For my hundredth question and answer video, I work through over a dozen questions in an hour. My blog for my podcasts and videos is found here: https

The First Day of Christmas: Twin Nativities

The First Day of Christmas: Twin Nativities

Alastair Roberts

December 25, 2018

Merry Christmas! Over the Christmas period, I will be posting videos exploring biblical echoes and symmetries in the stories of the nativity in the g

Q&A#97 How Did I Change My Mind on Infant Baptism?

Q&A#97 How Did I Change My Mind on Infant Baptism?

Alastair Roberts

December 11, 2018

Today's question: "As you have shared in several places, you came from a Reformed Baptist theological background and later moved to an Anglican settin

Q&A#96 Election in Ephesians 1

Q&A#96 Election in Ephesians 1

Alastair Roberts

December 9, 2018

Today's question: "Trying to understand Eph. 1 and was wondering if you could help. Paul seems to be addressing the visible/historical church in Ephes

Q&A#95 Must the Pastor be a Gifted Theologian?

Q&A#95 Must the Pastor be a Gifted Theologian?

Alastair Roberts

December 8, 2018

Today's question: "What do you think the relationship is between depth of theological understanding and being a good pastor? Is it a straight one to

More From "Alastair Roberts"

More on OpenTheo

What Tools of Reasoning Help You Know What’s True, Right, and Good?

What Tools of Reasoning Help You Know What’s True, Right, and Good?

December 4, 2025

Question about what tools of reasoning help us determine whether something is true or false, right or wrong, good or bad before bringing Scripture int

Can You Provide Verifiable, Non-Religious Evidence That a Supernatural Jesus Existed?

Can You Provide Verifiable, Non-Religious Evidence That a Supernatural Jesus Existed?

November 10, 2025

Question about providing verifiable, non-religious evidence that a supernatural Jesus existed. * I am an atheist and militantly anti-god-belief. Ho

What About Those Who Never Heard the Name of Jesus?

What About Those Who Never Heard the Name of Jesus?

December 22, 2025

Questions about what will happen to those who never heard of Jesus or were brought up in a different faith, whether there’s biblical warrant to think

Can You Recommend Good Books with More In-Depth Information and Ideas?

Can You Recommend Good Books with More In-Depth Information and Ideas?

January 22, 2026

Questions about good books on Christian apologetics, philosophy, and theology with more in-depth information and ideas, and resources to help an intel

Does God Really Need a “Pound of Flesh” to Forgive Sins?

Does God Really Need a “Pound of Flesh” to Forgive Sins?

January 12, 2026

Questions about how to answer the challenge that God doesn’t need a “pound of flesh” to forgive sins but can simply forgive, and whether the claim in

Brian Miller: Fine-Tuning and the Multiverse Theory

Brian Miller: Fine-Tuning and the Multiverse Theory

Knight & Rose Show

Wintery Knight and guest host Terrell Clemmons welcome Dr. Brian Miller to discuss the the evidence for fine-tuning in physics and cosmology and the m

Does Open-Mindedness Require Studying Other Religions Before Becoming a Christian?

Does Open-Mindedness Require Studying Other Religions Before Becoming a Christian?

February 9, 2026

Questions about the claim that if Christians really want to be open-minded, they need to read and study other religions before committing to Christian

How Would You Convince Someone That Evil Exists?

How Would You Convince Someone That Evil Exists?

November 17, 2025

Questions about how to convince someone that evil exists, whether Charlie Kirk’s murder was part of God’s plan, whether that would mean the murderer d

Is 1 Corinthians 12:3 a Black-and-White Tool for Discernment?

Is 1 Corinthians 12:3 a Black-and-White Tool for Discernment?

October 27, 2025

Questions about whether the claim in 1 Corinthians that “no one can say ‘Jesus is Lord’ except in the Holy Spirit” is a black-and-white tool for disce

Could the Writers of Scripture Have Been Influenced by Their Fallen Nature?

Could the Writers of Scripture Have Been Influenced by Their Fallen Nature?

October 23, 2025

Questions about whether or not it’s reasonable to worry that some of our current doctrines were influenced by the fallen nature of the apostles, and h

Is It Possible There’s a Being That’s Greater Than God?

Is It Possible There’s a Being That’s Greater Than God?

February 5, 2026

Questions about whether it’s possible there’s a being that’s greater than God and that’s outside of God’s comprehension and omniscience, and how to ex

Would You Say God’s Primary Object Is to Not Be Found?

Would You Say God’s Primary Object Is to Not Be Found?

Questions about whether God’s primary object is to not be found, how one can say God doesn’t make mistakes if the percentage of Christians in the worl

Who Wrote the Gospels? Michael Licona vs. Bart Ehrman - Part 2

Who Wrote the Gospels? Michael Licona vs. Bart Ehrman - Part 2

Did Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John write the gospels that bear their names? The texts themselves do not name them as the authors and were published and

Shouldn’t I Be Praying for My Soul Rather Than for Material Things?

Shouldn’t I Be Praying for My Soul Rather Than for Material Things?

February 2, 2026

Questions about whether we should be praying for our souls rather than for material things, why we need to pray about decisions, whether the devil can

How Can I Explain Modesty to My Daughter?

How Can I Explain Modesty to My Daughter?

November 27, 2025

Questions about how to explain modesty to a nine-year-old in a way that won’t cause shame about her body, and when and how to tell a child about a pre