OpenTheo

Q&A#5 Exegesis, Authorial Intention, and Typology

Alastair Roberts

Q&A#5 Exegesis, Authorial Intention, and Typology

May 18, 2018
Alastair Roberts
Alastair Roberts

Today's Question: Is the task of exegesis limited to discovering the author's original intention, or can meaning somehow overflow intention? If so, in what way? What guardrails are in place that would enable us to recognize certain readings as off-limits? A common text referenced in these discussions is Matthew 2:15's usage of Hosea 11:1, so I'd be interested to hear your take on that as well.

Leave your own questions in the comments, on my blog, or on my Curious Cat account.

http://alastairadversaria.com/

https://curiouscat.me/zugzwanged

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

How Would You Respond to Someone Referring to God as “She” in Church?
How Would You Respond to Someone Referring to God as “She” in Church?
#STRask
December 16, 2024
Questions about how to respond to someone referring to God as “she” during a church service, how to handle the tension between respecting the authorit
The Life and Ministry of R.C. Sproul with Stephen Nichols
The Life and Ministry of R.C. Sproul with Stephen Nichols
Life and Books and Everything
November 21, 2024
Recently, Steve Nichols spoke at the Faithful Conference, an annual conference for Christ Covenant Church. After giving a lecture on R.C. Sproul, Stev
Life on the Silent Planet (with Susannah Roberts, Rhys Laverty, & Jake Meador)
Life on the Silent Planet (with Susannah Roberts, Rhys Laverty, & Jake Meador)
Alastair Roberts
December 6, 2024
Rhys Laverty (Senior Editor at Ad Fontes and Senior Managing Editor of the Davenant Press), Jake Meador (Editor-in-Chief of Mere Orthodoxy), and Susan
Krista Bontrager and Monique Duson: Walking in Unity
Krista Bontrager and Monique Duson: Walking in Unity
Knight & Rose Show
November 16, 2024
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose welcome Krista Bontrager and Monique Duson to discuss their new book "Walking in Unity: Biblical Answers to Questions o
How Do We Know Moses Interpreted His Experiences of God Correctly?
How Do We Know Moses Interpreted His Experiences of God Correctly?
#STRask
November 4, 2024
Questions about how we know the biblical authors (Moses, etc.) interpreted their subjective experiences of receiving revelation from God correctly as
Evaluating the Thought of Cornelius Van Til with Keith Mathison and James Anderson
Evaluating the Thought of Cornelius Van Til with Keith Mathison and James Anderson
Life and Books and Everything
November 27, 2024
It is hard to exaggerate the influence of Cornelius Van Til (1895–1987) in conservative Reformed circles over the past hundred years. And yet, there c
If I’m Not Being Persecuted, Does That Mean I’m Not Living a Godly Life?
If I’m Not Being Persecuted, Does That Mean I’m Not Living a Godly Life?
#STRask
November 28, 2024
Questions about whether a lack of persecution means you’re not living a godly life, what to think about your faith if your suffering doesn’t bring you
What Does It Mean to Be an Evangelical? With Andrew Atherstone and David Ceri Jones
What Does It Mean to Be an Evangelical? With Andrew Atherstone and David Ceri Jones
Life and Books and Everything
October 23, 2024
A few months ago, a prominent American scholar, Matthew Avery Sutton, published an article arguing there is no “through line” from Christians of the p
Advent Hermeneutics
Advent Hermeneutics
Alastair Roberts
December 12, 2024
The following was first published over on The Anchored Argosy Substack: https://argosy.substack.com/p/42-an-obituary-and-advent. Follow my Substack,
How Can So Many Professing Christians Support Things That Are Anti-Christian?
How Can So Many Professing Christians Support Things That Are Anti-Christian?
#STRask
December 19, 2024
Questions about how so many professing Christians can support things that are anti-Christian, such as LGBTQ issues and abortion on demand, and how to
Why Should We Treat Everyone Respectfully?
Why Should We Treat Everyone Respectfully?
#STRask
November 21, 2024
Questions about why we should treat everyone respectfully, how to reconcile Jesus calling the Pharisees a brood of vipers with the instructions in 1 P
Should We Only Study the Truth in the Bible and Not Learn About Other Beliefs?
Should We Only Study the Truth in the Bible and Not Learn About Other Beliefs?
#STRask
October 17, 2024
Questions about whether we should only study the truth in the Bible and not learn about other beliefs, whether the apologetics approach is contrary to
Did Jesus Ever Experience Fear?
Did Jesus Ever Experience Fear?
#STRask
December 12, 2024
Questions about whether Jesus ever experienced fear, why Jesus would pray three times for something he already knew he would be denied, and a song tha
How Do You Convince a Former Christian That Jesus Is God?
How Do You Convince a Former Christian That Jesus Is God?
#STRask
November 14, 2024
Questions about how to convince a former Christian that Jesus is God, whether Jesus’ human nature was created, and what the Bible means when it says J
What Is the Mission of the Church? with Brian DeVries
What Is the Mission of the Church? with Brian DeVries
Life and Books and Everything
December 11, 2024
Mission is one of those words that Christians use all the time. So are words like “missions” and missionaries.” But what do they mean? Is “mission” ev