OpenTheo

Q&A#6 Trinity and Modalism

Alastair Roberts

Q&A#6 Trinity and Modalism

May 19, 2018
Alastair Roberts
Alastair Roberts

Today's Question: I follow what you are saying about the error of saying that there are three 'centers of consciousness' in God's Triune nature, and how that would involve a denial of the unity and simplicity of the Divine Being and ultimately involve tritheism. However, isn't that different from affirming three subsistent consciousnesses, or three self-conscious Persons within the nature of God? Would not a denial of that involve the opposite error of modalism? I am concerned that in our right concern to flee from tritheism, we are not seeing an implicit embrace of modalism.

Leave your own questions in the comments, on my blog, or on my Curious Cat account.

http://alastairadversaria.com/

https://curiouscat.me/zugzwanged

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

Life, and Ministry, and Laughter with Jason Helopoulos
Life, and Ministry, and Laughter with Jason Helopoulos
Life and Books and Everything
August 28, 2024
Listen as the two friends talk about the Land of Lincoln, about influential books and authors in their lives, and how the importance of friendship. Yo
When Does a Human Receive a Soul?
When Does a Human Receive a Soul?
#STRask
October 14, 2024
Questions about when a human receives a soul and how to respond to someone who rejects science, reason, philosophy, and objective morality in her effo
Why Mordecai Did Not Bow
Why Mordecai Did Not Bow
Alastair Roberts
October 12, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/breakfast-and-move-things. Follow our Substack, the Anchored Argosy at https
How Is Access to God in the New Covenant Different from the Old Covenant?
How Is Access to God in the New Covenant Different from the Old Covenant?
#STRask
August 29, 2024
Questions about how access to God through Jesus in the New Covenant differs from access in the Old Covenant, whether the salvation of Gentiles is just
Numbers and the Camp of Israel (with Michael Morales)
Numbers and the Camp of Israel (with Michael Morales)
Alastair Roberts
September 21, 2024
Michael Morales is the author of the recently released Numbers 1-19 volume (https://amzn.to/3XOgteK) in the Apollos Old Testament Commentary series, a
How Do We Know if the Good Things We Experience Are the Result of God’s Actions?
How Do We Know if the Good Things We Experience Are the Result of God’s Actions?
#STRask
October 7, 2024
Questions about how we know if the good things we experience are the result of God’s actions, whether something can be considered a miracle if it can
Selden College (with Dr Timothy Edwards)
Selden College (with Dr Timothy Edwards)
Alastair Roberts
October 21, 2024
Dr Timothy Edwards is Principal and Academic Dean of Selden College, a new Christian liberal arts college, which opens its doors to students in Octobe
How Would You Respond to the Current Mainstream View of the Historical Jesus?
How Would You Respond to the Current Mainstream View of the Historical Jesus?
#STRask
November 18, 2024
Questions about how to respond to the current mainstream view of the historical Jesus and the allegations that Jesus just ripped off material from anc
Some Lessons from Richard Hooker
Some Lessons from Richard Hooker
Alastair Roberts
November 13, 2024
The following was first published over on The Anchored Argosy Substack: https://argosy.substack.com/p/17-the-judicious-hooker. Within the episode I me
Krista Bontrager and Monique Duson: Walking in Unity
Krista Bontrager and Monique Duson: Walking in Unity
Knight & Rose Show
November 16, 2024
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose welcome Krista Bontrager and Monique Duson to discuss their new book "Walking in Unity: Biblical Answers to Questions o
Where Did the Essence God Is Composed of Come From?
Where Did the Essence God Is Composed of Come From?
#STRask
September 5, 2024
Questions about where the essence God is composed of came from, whether God has the same choices other beings have and could choose not to exist, and
What Can Be Learned From Contemporary, Non-Scriptural Greco-Roman writings?
What Can Be Learned From Contemporary, Non-Scriptural Greco-Roman writings?
Risen Jesus
August 26, 2024
In this episode, Dr. Mike Licona walks the listener through some of the discoveries revealed in his new book Jesus, Contradicted. By examining Greco-R
How Can I Help Someone Move Away from the Fact-Value Split?
How Can I Help Someone Move Away from the Fact-Value Split?
#STRask
September 23, 2024
Questions about how to help a friend move away from his belief that objective facts about religious issues, unlike scientific facts, are “just someone
How Would One Argue That a Particular Truth Is Self-Evident?
How Would One Argue That a Particular Truth Is Self-Evident?
#STRask
October 3, 2024
Questions about how one would argue that a particular truth is self-evident, the biblical justification for the claim of our Founding Fathers that God
Relitigating the Deception of Isaac
Relitigating the Deception of Isaac
Alastair Roberts
September 18, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/32-intellectual-salons-and-a-new. Follow our Substack, the Anchored Argosy a