OpenTheo

Q&A#6 Trinity and Modalism

Alastair Roberts

Q&A#6 Trinity and Modalism

May 19, 2018
Alastair Roberts
Alastair Roberts

Today's Question: I follow what you are saying about the error of saying that there are three 'centers of consciousness' in God's Triune nature, and how that would involve a denial of the unity and simplicity of the Divine Being and ultimately involve tritheism. However, isn't that different from affirming three subsistent consciousnesses, or three self-conscious Persons within the nature of God? Would not a denial of that involve the opposite error of modalism? I am concerned that in our right concern to flee from tritheism, we are not seeing an implicit embrace of modalism.

Leave your own questions in the comments, on my blog, or on my Curious Cat account.

http://alastairadversaria.com/

https://curiouscat.me/zugzwanged

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

Our Ancient Faith: Lincoln, Democracy, and the American Experiment with Allen Guelzo
Our Ancient Faith: Lincoln, Democracy, and the American Experiment with Allen Guelzo
Life and Books and Everything
February 14, 2024
He must be one of Kevin's favorite historians and favorite guests, because Dr. Guelzo is back for an unprecedented third visit to the LBE book-cave. A
The Pastor as Leader with John Currie
The Pastor as Leader with John Currie
Life and Books and Everything
April 17, 2024
With everything the pastor must do—preach, pray, visit, raise money, organize meetings, write emails, study, write, marry, bury, and baptize—does he a
Fatherlessness and Mass Shootings
Fatherlessness and Mass Shootings
For The King
March 27, 2024
What does fatherlessness have to do with mass shootings? Surprisingly, a whole lot! Samuel's Substack: https://samuelbornman.substack.com/p/save-the
What Should I Do if I Don’t Know How to Respond to Someone’s Answer to My Question?
What Should I Do if I Don’t Know How to Respond to Someone’s Answer to My Question?
#STRask
April 18, 2024
Questions about what to do when you don’t know how to respond to someone’s answer to your question and you feel unsafe in the conversation and how to
#211 Singleness, dating and being unequally yoked. Should christians date non-christians? What's the point of it all? Puzzled and pastoral questions this week with Tom
#211 Singleness, dating and being unequally yoked. Should christians date non-christians? What's the point of it all? Puzzled and pastoral questions this week with Tom
Ask NT Wright Anything
March 21, 2024
Help! I am a new christian and I'm worried I'm unequally yoked in my relationship? What is the biblical view of singleness? Should Christians date non
#213 Which Bible Translation is the best one? (Replay)
#213 Which Bible Translation is the best one? (Replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
April 4, 2024
Listeners ask questions on which Bible translations we should deem as the best ones and which ones we should use on a daily basis. What makes a good t
Tree?!? I am no Tree!!!
Tree?!? I am no Tree!!!
For The King
April 17, 2024
The LOTR trilogy has some amazing principles on how we think about the enchantment of nature. We hope you are edified during this discussion! Key Te
#216 Title Dear Tom: What does the Bible say about the Spiritual Gifts?
#216 Title Dear Tom: What does the Bible say about the Spiritual Gifts?
Ask NT Wright Anything
April 25, 2024
Tom discusses the relevance of spiritual gifts like prophecy and speaking in tongues within our modern context, dives into the significance of signs a
Is There Something I Can Do to Develop Love for Christ if I Am Emotionally Detached?
Is There Something I Can Do to Develop Love for Christ if I Am Emotionally Detached?
#STRask
March 14, 2024
Questions about whether there is something a person can do to develop love for Christ if they are emotionally detached and whether one should stay in
The Transfiguration of Christ (with Patrick Schreiner)
The Transfiguration of Christ (with Patrick Schreiner)
Alastair Roberts
March 21, 2024
Patrick Schreiner joins me to discuss his wonderful new book, 'The Transfiguration of Christ: An Exegetical and Theological Reading': https://amzn.to/
Why Do Atheists Get Angry When I Bring up Belief in God?
Why Do Atheists Get Angry When I Bring up Belief in God?
#STRask
March 11, 2024
Questions about why atheists get angry when someone brings up belief in God, how to reconcile God’s sovereignty and Satan being the prince of the worl
Historian Mike Licona Investigates the Resurrection
Historian Mike Licona Investigates the Resurrection
Knight & Rose Show
March 23, 2024
Just in time for Easter, Wintery Knight and Desert Rose interview Dr. Michael Licona about how historians can investigate miracle claims, such as the
Where Have All the Fundamentalists Gone?
Where Have All the Fundamentalists Gone?
Life and Books and Everything
March 6, 2024
With two smart British historians—one from Oxford (Andrew) and one from Aberystwyth (David)--and one curious American pastor (Kevin), you might say th
Is It Okay to Be Part of a Music Ministry That’s Led by a Professing Mormon?
Is It Okay to Be Part of a Music Ministry That’s Led by a Professing Mormon?
#STRask
April 11, 2024
Questions about whether it’s okay to be part of a music ministry that’s led by a professing Mormon, whether a woman should date a man who isn’t as spi
Conspiracy Theory and Autodidact Brain (with Susannah Roberts and Derek Rishmawy)
Conspiracy Theory and Autodidact Brain (with Susannah Roberts and Derek Rishmawy)
Alastair Roberts
April 20, 2024
The journalist and writer Naomi Wolf recently posted on Twitter about her reading of a New Testament interlinear: https://twitter.com/naomirwolf/statu