OpenTheo

Jesus' Bodily Resurrection - A Legendary Development Based on Hallucinations - Licona vs. Carrier - Part 1

Risen Jesus — Mike Licona

Jesus' Bodily Resurrection - A Legendary Development Based on Hallucinations - Licona vs. Carrier - Part 1

March 5, 2025
Risen Jesus
Risen JesusMike Licona

In this episode, a 2004 debate between Mike Licona and Richard Carrier, Licona presents a case for the resurrection of Jesus based on three facts that are strongly evidenced and acknowledged by the majority of scholars: 1) Jesus’ death by crucifixion, 2) the empty tomb, and 3) the experiences of Jesus’ disciples and his enemy Saul that they believed were appearances of the risen Jesus. Carrier contends that the earliest Christians only held that Jesus’ soul was exalted and that the idea of a bodily resurrection, and the gospel testimony in favor of this, came later through Paul. Who makes the stronger case?

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

How Could God Be Perfect If He Regrets Something He Did?
How Could God Be Perfect If He Regrets Something He Did?
#STRask
February 24, 2025
Questions about how God could be perfect if he regrets something he did, whether there’s a difference between God’s sovereignty and God’s providence,
Called to Freedom (with Brad Littlejohn)
Called to Freedom (with Brad Littlejohn)
Alastair Roberts
January 15, 2025
My friend and colleague Brad Littlejohn has a new book coming out, 'Called to Freedom: Retrieving Christian Liberty in an Age of License': https://amz
A Life of Hope and Hurdles with Andre Levrone and Sydney McLaughlin Levrone
A Life of Hope and Hurdles with Andre Levrone and Sydney McLaughlin Levrone
Life and Books and Everything
January 10, 2025
How can you shine as a Christian in the world of professional sports—when sometimes your dreams come true and often they don’t? What does it take to b
John West: Stockholm Syndrome Christianity
John West: Stockholm Syndrome Christianity
Knight & Rose Show
February 8, 2025
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose welcome Vice President of the Discovery Institute Dr. John West to discuss his new book "Stockholm Syndrome Christianit
Are All Sins Equal to God?
Are All Sins Equal to God?
#STRask
January 9, 2025
Questions about whether God looks at all sins as being equally severe, how to reconcile Jesus’ statements that judgment will be degreed with the idea
Indiana SB 483: Regulation of Homeschooling with IAHE Legislative Liaison Kylene Varner
Indiana SB 483: Regulation of Homeschooling with IAHE Legislative Liaison Kylene Varner
For The King
February 12, 2025
The Bill IAHE Website -> Make sure to follow the twitter page IAHE Action website -> Make sure to sign up for the newsletter and the twitter page Home
How Should I Pray About Big Decisions If I Can’t Expect a Confirmation from God?
How Should I Pray About Big Decisions If I Can’t Expect a Confirmation from God?
#STRask
January 2, 2025
Questions about how we should pray about big decisions if we can’t expect to hear a “yes“ or “no” from God, what Greg means by “listening prayer,” and
Is God Just a Way of Solving a Mystery by Appealing to a Greater Mystery?
Is God Just a Way of Solving a Mystery by Appealing to a Greater Mystery?
#STRask
March 17, 2025
Questions about whether God is just a way of solving a mystery by appealing to a greater mystery, whether subjective experience falls under a category
How Can Those Who Are Happy with the Election Results Show Compassion to Those Who Are Devastated?
How Can Those Who Are Happy with the Election Results Show Compassion to Those Who Are Devastated?
#STRask
January 16, 2025
Questions about how those who are happy with the election results can show compassion to those who are devastated, navigating a relationship with an a
A Very Special Episode with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
A Very Special Episode with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Life and Books and Everything
January 16, 2025
There has been some concern that Justin and Collin have been kept out of the “very special guest” designation. In order to make up for past offenses,
The Person and Work of Christ with Brandon Crowe
The Person and Work of Christ with Brandon Crowe
Life and Books and Everything
January 31, 2025
Kevin welcomes to the podcast Brandon Crowe, a native Alabamian, an SEC fan, a Teaching Elder in the PCA, and a professor of New Testament at Westmins
What Should I Say to Active Churchgoers Who Reject the Trinity and the Deity of Christ?
What Should I Say to Active Churchgoers Who Reject the Trinity and the Deity of Christ?
#STRask
March 13, 2025
Questions about what to say to longtime, active churchgoers who don’t believe in the Trinity or the deity of Christ, and a challenge to the idea that
Does Scripture Support a Christian Church Joining in Worship Services with an LDS Church?
Does Scripture Support a Christian Church Joining in Worship Services with an LDS Church?
#STRask
February 6, 2025
Questions about whether there’s Scripture to support a Christian church joining in worship services with an LDS church, whether it’s a genetic fallacy
Who Made You the Experts on What Makes Someone a Christian?
Who Made You the Experts on What Makes Someone a Christian?
#STRask
January 27, 2025
Questions about whether Greg and Amy are illegitimately claiming they’re the experts on what makes someone a Christian and a tactic to use with someon
If Christians Believe God Answers Prayer, Then Why Do They Buy Health Insurance?
If Christians Believe God Answers Prayer, Then Why Do They Buy Health Insurance?
#STRask
February 13, 2025
Questions about why Christians buy health insurance if they really believe God answers prayer and whether or not one should end all prayers about desi