Lydia McGrew Answered! Black & White Thinking

Risen Jesus — Mike Licona

Lydia McGrew Answered! Black & White Thinking

June 17, 2024

Risen Jesus

Risen JesusMike Licona

In this episode, part 4 in an 8 part series, Dr. Licona demonstrates Lydia McGrew’s rigid approach that’s founded upon her presumptions pertaining to ancient historical reporting. Her black and white thinking leads to an all-or-nothing approach, exaggerated opinions, and inaccurate conclusions about how the ancients reported the past. Moreover, she often interprets those she criticizes in a manner that’s both inaccurate and uncharitable. These audio clips are taken from Dr. Licona’s YouTube channel, originally published in 2020.

Share

Transcript

More From Risen Jesus

Lydia McGrew Answered! On Plutarch

Lydia McGrew Answered! On Plutarch

In this episode, part 5 in an 8 part series, Dr. Licona patiently deconstructs Lydia McGrew’s contrived flow chart for determining when it is safe to

Lydia McGrew Answered! More Methodological Missteps

Lydia McGrew Answered! More Methodological Missteps

In this episode, Dr. Licona walks us through more missteps by Lydia Mcgrew, including false dichotomies on the issues of chronological narration, and

Lydia McGrew Answered! On Gospel Differences

Lydia McGrew Answered! On Gospel Differences

In this episode, part 7 in an 8 part series, Dr. Licona reviews several events in the Gospels to demonstrate how compositional devices are more plausi

Lydia McGrew Answered! On Paraphrase

Lydia McGrew Answered! On Paraphrase

In this episode, Dr. Licona gives attention to Lydia McGrew's contentions that historians in antiquity would not have employed the literary exercises

Lydia McGrew Answered! Are the Gospels Greco-Roman Biographies?

Lydia McGrew Answered! Are the Gospels Greco-Roman Biographies?

In this episode, part 2 of 8 in a series, Dr. Licona answers Lydia McGrew's contention that the Gospels are not affiliated with Greco-Roman biography.

Lydia McGrew Answered! An Introduction

Lydia McGrew Answered! An Introduction

In this episode, part 1 of 8 in a series, Dr. Licona describes his research on Gospel differences and introduces us to a critical assessment of his wo

More From "Risen Jesus"

More on OpenTheo

What Does a Personal Relationship with God Look Like on a Practical Level?

What Does a Personal Relationship with God Look Like on a Practical Level?

Questions about how to explain what a personal relationship with God looks like on a practical level and whether it’s okay to pray to Jesus and to the

What Should I Say to a Reformed Christian Who Dismisses Many Non-Believers as Lost Causes?

What Should I Say to a Reformed Christian Who Dismisses Many Non-Believers as Lost Causes?

Questions about the best way to respond to someone who believes in double predestination and who dismisses many non-believers as lost causes and wheth

Your Identity in Christ and the Difference it Makes

Your Identity in Christ and the Difference it Makes

Knight & Rose Show

Wintery Knight and Desert Rose discuss the concept of "identity in Christ". We discuss how your identity in Christ changes your desires, capabilities,

Drinking, Merriment, and Heaven

Drinking, Merriment, and Heaven

What is the biblical view of alcohol? https://fortheking.substack.com/p/drinking-merriment-and-heaven Parallel Christian Economy * ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Ref

Why Would You Say Evolution Has No Purpose?

Why Would You Say Evolution Has No Purpose?

Questions about the claim that evolution has no purpose and whether the fact that people who have aphantasia are unable to form mental images shows th

The Internet is the Negative World

The Internet is the Negative World

Alastair Roberts

The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/33-the-internet-is-the-negative-world. Within it, I discuss Aaron Renn's rece

Casey Luskin: Debunking the Myth of Junk DNA

Casey Luskin: Debunking the Myth of Junk DNA

Knight & Rose Show

Wintery Knight and Desert Rose interview Dr. Casey Luskin about junk DNA. Is your DNA assembled by undirected forces, or is it intelligently designed?

Is an Embryo a Baby?

Is an Embryo a Baby?

Questions about whether the fact that you can freeze an embryo but not a baby proves an embryo isn’t a baby and whether it would be wrong to use IVF w

What Should I Say to a Reformed Christian Who Dismisses Many Non-Believers as Lost Causes?

What Should I Say to a Reformed Christian Who Dismisses Many Non-Believers as Lost Causes?

Questions about the best way to respond to someone who believes in double predestination and who dismisses many non-believers as lost causes and wheth

Is Church Just a Man-Made Way to Control People?

Is Church Just a Man-Made Way to Control People?

Questions about what to say to someone who believes the Bible and church are man-made ways to control people who don’t want to think for themselves an

Theologian Krista Bontrager on Diversity

Theologian Krista Bontrager on Diversity

Knight & Rose Show

Wintery Knight and Desert Rose interview Krista Bontrager about diversity, equity and inclusion. What is diversity? Are there any benefits to diversit

How Should a Dad Talk to His Children about Attending Their Mom’s Same-Sex Wedding?

How Should a Dad Talk to His Children about Attending Their Mom’s Same-Sex Wedding?

Questions about how a dad should talk to his children about attending their mom’s same-sex wedding, how a veterinarian should respond if someone who s

What’s the Best Evidence for the Reliability of the Old Testament?

What’s the Best Evidence for the Reliability of the Old Testament?

Questions about the best evidence for the reliability of the Old Testament, whether Greg subscribes to the idea of four independent Gospel accounts or

Lydia McGrew Answered! More Methodological Missteps

Lydia McGrew Answered! More Methodological Missteps

In this episode, Dr. Licona walks us through more missteps by Lydia Mcgrew, including false dichotomies on the issues of chronological narration, and

Lydia McGrew Answered! Are the Gospels Greco-Roman Biographies?

Lydia McGrew Answered! Are the Gospels Greco-Roman Biographies?

In this episode, part 2 of 8 in a series, Dr. Licona answers Lydia McGrew's contention that the Gospels are not affiliated with Greco-Roman biography.