OpenTheo

Does Christianity Transcend All Our Political Disagreements?

Life and Books and Everything — Clearly Reformed
00:00
00:00

Does Christianity Transcend All Our Political Disagreements?

October 28, 2022
Life and Books and Everything
Life and Books and EverythingClearly Reformed

Christians don’t just disagree on political principles or on a number of political conclusions. Christians disagree on how Christianity and politics relate to each other in the first place.

In this episode of Life and Books and Everything, Kevin reads his recent article in WORLD opinions, "Does Christianity Transcend All Our Political Disagreements?"

Share

Transcript

[music]
Greetings and salutations. This is Life in Books and Everything. I'm Kevin DeYoung.
I'm reading today my latest article in World Opinions.
Be sure to check out World Opinions Online. This article is entitled "Does Christianity Transcend All Our Political Disagreements?" Right and Wrong Ways to Think about Christianity and Politics.
This is a continuing part of the series that I've been doing in World Opinions, thinking about a number of different questions related to Christianity and politics. So here's the latest. Americans are polarized by politics.
Everyone recognizes that political differences in this country are deep and seem to be growing. The division is present everywhere, including in the church. Moreover, Christians don't just disagree on political principles or on a number of political conclusions.
Christians disagree on how Christianity and politics relate to each other in the first place. In an essay, it's impossible to even begin to sketch a proper answer to such a massive topic, but maybe we can set a few planks in place, playing off of Richard Neiber's famous Christ and culture categories, by noting what is right and wrong with four common approaches. 1. Christianity Against Politics.
Christians with this approach are usually happy to blast both parties, or all parties if you have more than two. They may believe that politics is important and that voting matters and that certain issues really matter, but Christianity is largely seen as something that stands opposed to the messy, often idolatrous world of politics. On the positive side, this approach understands that the gospel of Christ is not mainly about fixing the social order, and that the Bible was not written to lay out a political system.
The Christianity Against Politics approach is strong on warning Christians against putting too much hope in kings and in earthly kingdoms. On the negative side, Christians with this approach are often uninterested in learning the intellectual contours of political science or in the long history of moral philosophy. They can also be unrealistic about how political and social change happens.
Politics is about the art of the possible, which requires making the best out of a fallen world filled with sinful people and imperfect systems. 2. Christianity Above Politics. In this approach, Christianity is seen as "the truth" capital T that transcends all earthly systems.
Christians with this approach are interested in the study of politics and in the various historical isms that have been tried in the political realm. These Christians believe that the gospel provides the proper critique to all man-made systems of political, economic, and social ordering. On the positive side, this approach understands that Christianity is not to be identified with any particular political philosophy, political party, or intellectual tradition.
On the negative side, the gospel critiques can often be superficial and lead to a sloppy moral equivalence. Thus, the Christian approach ends up being the supposed "golden mean" between conservatism and progressivism, or the imaginary midpoint between Marxism and capitalism. Every historical system, no matter how evil or how failed, gets presented with a few strings and a few weaknesses, and none is really better or worse than another.
3. Christianity as Politics. In this approach, the message of Christianity and the task of the individual Christian is seen as irreducibly political. For some Christians, this entails a civil religion that blends elements of American history, democratic sensibilities, and national patriotism with Orthodox Christianity.
For others, Christianity as politics looks like a bold plan for social transformation, political conquest, and the exercise of power in an effort to bring about a truly Christian culture. On the positive side, Christians with this approach understand that Jesus is Lord overall. They recognize that there is no domain called politics that can be, or should be, quarantined off from the rest of Christian discipleship.
On the negative side, this approach often has too much already and too little, not yet. Christians with this approach can also be dogmatic about policies and prescriptions that are prudential matters needing Christian wisdom and forbearance. This approach often neglects the doctrine of the spirituality of the church and can lose sight of the fact that the church's power, competence, and mission are not unlimited.
4. Christianity under politics. In this approach, Christian ideas and Christian communities are seen as essential to a healthy political order. Christians with this mindset are often eager to defend Western civilization in the Anglo-American tradition of Republican, small R, virtue, and ordered liberty.
Christianity is valued as foundational and indispensable for the human pursuit of the good, the true, and the beautiful. On the positive side, this approach understands and appreciates the role of Christianity and the role it has played in the development of Western culture and in the establishment of a free and prosperous people. There is also wisdom in recognizing that Christianity does not offer a full-blown political philosophy, but that the best moral philosophy will be built upon a Christian view of the human person and of human nature.
On the negative side, this approach can reduce the Christian faith as something of utilitarian value. The church, its mission, its doctrine, and its worship often become secondary, while the nation-state or a civilizational tradition becomes primary. There is a danger that Christians become more zealous for liberty or social justice or national greatness than for Jesus Christ, for the gospel, and for the glory of God.
So where does this leave us? I don't have my own neatly labeled approach to offer, but appropriating the insights in each approach while avoiding the dangers would be a good place to start. We need an approach to politics that is engaged, but not idolatrous, transcendent, but not relativizing, culture shaping, but also constrained, supportive of a broader Christianity infused tradition, while also insisting that Christ is our first love, and not that tradition.
[MUSIC]

More From Life and Books and Everything

A World Awash in Sheer Monkery
A World Awash in Sheer Monkery
Life and Books and Everything
November 2, 2022
Reformation Day may be behind us, but a huge responsibility lies before us. The faith of the Reformation must be kept alive because the ideas Luther c
Positive World, Negative World, and Christian Nationalism with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Positive World, Negative World, and Christian Nationalism with Justin Taylor and Collin Hansen
Life and Books and Everything
November 8, 2022
The three amigos enter into a meandering conversation about Christian Nationalism and try to discern the level of the world’s hostility to the church
Liberty, Pandora, and the Serpent
Liberty, Pandora, and the Serpent
Life and Books and Everything
November 11, 2022
Was America founded on purely Christian principles and ideals? Or, were the founding fathers simply trying to prevent corruption and preserve the sanc
Life and Ministry with Sinclair Ferguson
Life and Ministry with Sinclair Ferguson
Life and Books and Everything
October 25, 2022
Have you ever wanted to sit down with an older godly pastor and just ask him about life for an hour? Well, that’s what Kevin tries to do with Sinclair
The Case for Kids
The Case for Kids
Life and Books and Everything
October 20, 2022
Too often Christian leaders lay impossible burdens on their people, insisting that they solve a host of social ills and become experts in a thousand d
Evangelicalism, Elites, and Excellence with Aaron Renn
Evangelicalism, Elites, and Excellence with Aaron Renn
Life and Books and Everything
October 12, 2022
Coming out of a consulting background, Aaron Renn is now a regular contributor to many important conversations among Christians and conservatives. In
More From "Life and Books and Everything"

More on OpenTheo

What Should I Say to Someone Who Believes Zodiac Signs Determine Personality?
What Should I Say to Someone Who Believes Zodiac Signs Determine Personality?
#STRask
June 5, 2025
Questions about how to respond to a family member who believes Zodiac signs determine personality and what to say to a co-worker who believes aliens c
If Sin Is a Disease We’re Born with, How Can We Be Guilty When We Sin?
If Sin Is a Disease We’re Born with, How Can We Be Guilty When We Sin?
#STRask
June 19, 2025
Questions about how we can be guilty when we sin if sin is a disease we’re born with, how it can be that we’ll have free will in Heaven but not have t
If Jesus Is God, Why Didn’t He Know the Day of His Return?
If Jesus Is God, Why Didn’t He Know the Day of His Return?
#STRask
June 12, 2025
Questions about why Jesus didn’t know the day of his return if he truly is God, and why it’s important for Jesus to be both fully God and fully man.  
The Biblical View of Abortion with Tom Pennington
The Biblical View of Abortion with Tom Pennington
Life and Books and Everything
May 5, 2025
What does the Bible say about life in the womb? When does life begin? What about personhood? What has the church taught about abortion over the centur
Is It Wrong to Feel Satisfaction at the Thought of Some Atheists Being Humbled Before Christ?
Is It Wrong to Feel Satisfaction at the Thought of Some Atheists Being Humbled Before Christ?
#STRask
June 9, 2025
Questions about whether it’s wrong to feel a sense of satisfaction at the thought of some atheists being humbled before Christ when their time comes,
Michael Egnor and Denyse O'Leary: The Immortal Mind
Michael Egnor and Denyse O'Leary: The Immortal Mind
Knight & Rose Show
May 31, 2025
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose interview Dr. Michael Egnor and Denyse O'Leary about their new book "The Immortal Mind". They discuss how scientific ev
Is Morality Determined by Society?
Is Morality Determined by Society?
#STRask
June 26, 2025
Questions about how to respond to someone who says morality is determined by society, whether our evolutionary biology causes us to think it’s objecti
The Resurrection: A Matter of History or Faith? Licona and Pagels on the Ron Isana Show
The Resurrection: A Matter of History or Faith? Licona and Pagels on the Ron Isana Show
Risen Jesus
July 2, 2025
In this episode, we have a 2005 appearance of Dr. Mike Licona on the Ron Isana Show, where he defends the historicity of the bodily resurrection of Je
Mythos or Logos: How Should the Narratives about Jesus' Resurreciton Be Understood? Licona/Craig vs Spangenberg/Wolmarans
Mythos or Logos: How Should the Narratives about Jesus' Resurreciton Be Understood? Licona/Craig vs Spangenberg/Wolmarans
Risen Jesus
April 16, 2025
Dr. Mike Licona and Dr. Willian Lane Craig contend that the texts about Jesus’ resurrection were written to teach a physical, historical resurrection
What Should I Teach My Students About Worldviews?
What Should I Teach My Students About Worldviews?
#STRask
June 2, 2025
Question about how to go about teaching students about worldviews, what a worldview is, how to identify one, how to show that the Christian worldview
What Would You Say to Someone Who Believes in “Healing Frequencies”?
What Would You Say to Someone Who Believes in “Healing Frequencies”?
#STRask
May 8, 2025
Questions about what to say to someone who believes in “healing frequencies” in fabrics and music, whether Christians should use Oriental medicine tha
Is It Problematic for a DJ to Play Songs That Are Contrary to His Christian Values?
Is It Problematic for a DJ to Play Songs That Are Contrary to His Christian Values?
#STRask
July 10, 2025
Questions about whether it’s problematic for a DJ on a secular radio station to play songs with lyrics that are contrary to his Christian values, and
What Would Be the Point of Getting Baptized After All This Time?
What Would Be the Point of Getting Baptized After All This Time?
#STRask
May 22, 2025
Questions about the point of getting baptized after being a Christian for over 60 years, the difference between a short prayer and an eloquent one, an
What Are the Top Five Things to Consider Before Joining a Church?
What Are the Top Five Things to Consider Before Joining a Church?
#STRask
July 3, 2025
Questions about the top five things to consider before joining a church when coming out of the NAR movement, and thoughts regarding a church putting o
Full Preterism/Dispensationalism: Hermeneutics that Crucified Jesus
Full Preterism/Dispensationalism: Hermeneutics that Crucified Jesus
For The King
June 29, 2025
Full Preterism is heresy and many forms of Dispensationalism is as well. We hope to show why both are insufficient for understanding biblical prophecy