OpenTheo

How Did Sexual Identity Politics Win?, with Carl Trueman

Life and Books and Everything — Clearly Reformed

How Did Sexual Identity Politics Win?, with Carl Trueman

November 24, 2020
Life and Books and Everything
Life and Books and EverythingClearly Reformed

In this episode of Life and Books and Everything, Carl Trueman joins Kevin, Justin, and Collin to discuss his latest book, published by Crossway, which analyzes the development of the sexual revolution as a symptom—rather than the cause—of the human search for identity. You’ll also learn the benefit for Christians of reading Nietzsche and Freud, and what you can say to someone when there isn’t time to debate the philosophy of gender.   

Timestamps: 

Thirty-second long book title [00:55 – 1:25] 

If identity is sexual, then sex is political. [1:25 – 7:37] 

Behaviors demand toleration; identity demands recognition. [7:37 – 13:39] 

Grappling with the history of ideas [13:39 – 22:26] 

Intended audience [22:26 – 24:29] 

Why Carl wants to be called a bigot [24:29 – 28:32] 

Should pastors read these non-Christian authors? [28:32 – 34:18] 

Is Protestantism to blame for sexual identity politics? [34:18 – 44:48] 

Natural law will help us communicate to younger generations. [44:48 – 50:55] 

What can you say to the other side when there isn’t time to debate? [50:55 –56:16] 

Against lament? [56:16 – 57:50] 

Family shapes theology. [57:50 – 1:03:00] 

Books and Everything: 

The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self: Cultural Amnesia, ExpressiveIndividualism, and the Road to Sexual Revolution, by Carl R. Trueman 

Civilization & Its Discontents, by Sigmund Freud 

The Triumph of the Therapeutic, by Philip Rieff 

Living in God's Two Kingdoms: A Biblical Vision for Christianity and Culture,by David VanDrunen 

Hands Across the Aisle 

“The Fury of the Fatherless,” by Mary Eberstadt, First Things  

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

What Does It Mean to Be an Evangelical? With Andrew Atherstone and David Ceri Jones
What Does It Mean to Be an Evangelical? With Andrew Atherstone and David Ceri Jones
Life and Books and Everything
October 23, 2024
A few months ago, a prominent American scholar, Matthew Avery Sutton, published an article arguing there is no “through line” from Christians of the p
The Church and Politics (with Miles Smith IV)
The Church and Politics (with Miles Smith IV)
Alastair Roberts
October 15, 2024
Dr Miles Smith, Assistant Professor of History at Hillsdale College, joins me to discuss the complexities of the Church's relationship with politics.
How Can I Help Someone Move Away from the Fact-Value Split?
How Can I Help Someone Move Away from the Fact-Value Split?
#STRask
September 23, 2024
Questions about how to help a friend move away from his belief that objective facts about religious issues, unlike scientific facts, are “just someone
Do We Always Need to Make the Case that Christian Morality Is the Best Way to Live?
Do We Always Need to Make the Case that Christian Morality Is the Best Way to Live?
#STRask
September 26, 2024
Questions about whether Christians can simply say that God’s moral requirements are a show of loyalty to him rather than argue they’re the best way to
How Is Biblical Inspiration Different from Automatic Writing?
How Is Biblical Inspiration Different from Automatic Writing?
#STRask
October 31, 2024
Questions about how biblical inspiration differs from automatic writing, whether or not we don’t know who wrote 74% of the New Testament, signing a ma
What Would You Say in a High School Graduation Speech?
What Would You Say in a High School Graduation Speech?
#STRask
September 16, 2024
Questions about what we would say in a high school graduation speech if given the opportunity, how to talk to talk about eternity with a six-year-old
Does the Bible Explicitly Forbid Premarital Sex?
Does the Bible Explicitly Forbid Premarital Sex?
#STRask
September 30, 2024
Questions about whether the Bible explicitly forbids premarital sex and whether Song of Songs 2:4–6 promotes premarital sex.   * How should I respond
Numbers and the Camp of Israel (with Michael Morales)
Numbers and the Camp of Israel (with Michael Morales)
Alastair Roberts
September 21, 2024
Michael Morales is the author of the recently released Numbers 1-19 volume (https://amzn.to/3XOgteK) in the Apollos Old Testament Commentary series, a
Guillermo Gonzalez: Earth is Designed for Discovery
Guillermo Gonzalez: Earth is Designed for Discovery
Knight & Rose Show
October 26, 2024
Wintery Knight and Desert Rose welcome Dr. Guillermo Gonzalez to discuss the new 20th anniversary edition of "The Privileged Planet". Guillermo explai
A Fresh Look at Inerrancy: Part two
A Fresh Look at Inerrancy: Part two
Risen Jesus
September 3, 2024
What are compositional devices? How do they affect our view of inerrancy? What does the Bible say about inspiration and inerrancy? In this episode, Dr
What Do I Tell a Child Who Feels Guilty for Not Wanting to Read the Bible?
What Do I Tell a Child Who Feels Guilty for Not Wanting to Read the Bible?
#STRask
September 19, 2024
Questions about what to tell a child who feels guilty for not wanting to read the Bible because he finds it boring and confusing, what Bible was print
Why Emphasize Evangelism When the Bible Only Mentions the Great Commission Four Times?
Why Emphasize Evangelism When the Bible Only Mentions the Great Commission Four Times?
#STRask
August 22, 2024
Questions about why evangelism is emphasized above other commands in the Bible, what to do when speaking the truth in love hurts someone’s feelings, a
What Can Be Learned From Contemporary, Non-Scriptural Greco-Roman writings?
What Can Be Learned From Contemporary, Non-Scriptural Greco-Roman writings?
Risen Jesus
August 26, 2024
In this episode, Dr. Mike Licona walks the listener through some of the discoveries revealed in his new book Jesus, Contradicted. By examining Greco-R
Why Mordecai Did Not Bow
Why Mordecai Did Not Bow
Alastair Roberts
October 12, 2024
The following is a reading from this post: https://argosy.substack.com/p/breakfast-and-move-things. Follow our Substack, the Anchored Argosy at https
Is It Circular Reasoning to Say the Bible Is True Because God Says It’s True?
Is It Circular Reasoning to Say the Bible Is True Because God Says It’s True?
#STRask
August 19, 2024
Questions about whether it’s circular reasoning to say the Bible is true because God says it’s true, how we can know when sarcasm or some other releva